CO129-293 - Governor Sir Blake - 1899 [8-9] — Page 545

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

C. O.

29323

Minute by Major-General Gascoigne.

542

Your Excellency,

!

I do not know that I have anything to add to my previous remarks.

It is a matter of regret to me that the first opinion I was called upon to express officially after my arrival in the Colony should be unfavourable to a scheme which it appeared was desired by a large number of residents.

There can be no question whatever that the making of this road would now be a source of weakness in a defensive sense, not rather the reverse.

It would be an increase of anxiety, and would probably necessitate some alteration in the scheme of defence.

Therefore any military Commander, if asked whether he preferred that the road should or should not be made, would be bound to reply that he preferred that it should not be.

At the same time if Your Excellency informed me that to make this road would satisfy a great and pressing need for the Colony generally I should consider

Edit History

2026-05-31 08:13:19 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
C. O. 29323 Minute by Major-General Gascoigne. 542 Your Excellency, ! I do not know that I have anything to add to my previous remarks. It is a matter of regret to me that the first opinion I was called upon to express officially after my arrival in the Colony should be unfavourable to a scheme which it appeared was desired by a large number of residents. There can be no question whatever that the making of this road would now be a source of weakness in a defensive sense, not rather the reverse. It would be an increase of anxiety, and would probably necessitate some alteration in the scheme of defence. Therefore any military Commander, if asked whether he preferred that the road should or should not be made, would be bound to reply that he preferred that it should not be. At the same time if Your Excellency informed me that to make this road would satisfy a great and pressing need for the Colony generally I should consider
Baseline (Original)
OPY C. O. 29323 Minute by Major-Gercond Gascoigne. 542 Your Txcellency. ! I do not know that I have anything to red to my previous remarks. It s r mbter of regre: to me that the first opinion I was crlled upon to expreen officially after my arrival in the Colory should be undevorsble to F scheme which it appeared vas desired by a large number of residents Where can be no question whatever that the making of this rord would nou be a rource of strength in a defensive rense,not rether the reverse. It would be an inorese of anxieny,end would probably recessita be some alteretion in the rchene of defence. Therefore any lilitery Commander, if esked whether he preferred that the road should or should not be de would be bound to reply that he preferred that it should not be. At the crme time if Your Excellency informed me that to make this road would satisfy a great should not and pressing ne-a for the Colors generelly I shoul consider
2026-05-31 08:13:19 · Baseline
View content

OPY

C. O.

29323

Minute by Major-Gercond

Gascoigne.

542

Your Txcellency.

!

I do not know that I have anything to red

to my previous remarks.

It s r mbter of regre: to me that the

first opinion I was crlled upon to expreen officially

after my arrival in the Colory should be undevorsble to

F scheme which it appeared vas desired by a large number

of residents

Where can be no question whatever that

the making of this rord would nou be a rource of strength

in a defensive rense,not rether the reverse.

It would be an inorese of anxieny,end

would probably recessita be some alteretion in the rchene

of defence. Therefore any lilitery Commander, if esked

whether he preferred that the road should or should not

be de would be bound to reply that he preferred that

it should not be. At the crme time if Your Excellency

informed me that to make this road would satisfy a great

should not

and pressing ne-a for the Colors generelly I shoul

consider

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.